WCC wimps out on marriage equality

Posted on September 1, 2015 | 7 comments

wedding cake

Despite a majority of W’bool City Councillors declaring their support for marriage equality, only two argued to do anything about it. Image: Politichicks.com

Comment – Carol Altmann

When it comes to showing some spine on marriage equality, the majority of the Warrnambool City Council has proven, sadly, that they have none.

We know this because yesterday (31/8) the council had an opportunity to actually stand up and be counted on same sex marriage and they didn’t even make it to first base.

This is despite a majority of councillors telling Bluestone just two months ago that they had no problem with marriage equality, none at all, yet when it came to doing something about it, five of the seven councillors ran the other way.

How hypocritical.

Here is what happened.

As I mentioned in an earlier piece, Byron Shire Council Mayor Simon Richardson contacted the WCC by letter, asking for it to join a growing number of councils around Australia who have endorsed marriage equality as a civil right.

(Mayor Richardson who, for the record, has a female partner and two daughters, has taken a national lead on the marriage equality campaign within local government and has also formed a Mayors for Marriage Equality group.)

More than a dozen councils around Australia have so far declared their support for marriage equality, including Hobart City Council, Albury, Glen Eira, Greater Geelong- Surf Coast, Tenterfield, Byron Shire, Sydney, Leichardt and Port Douglas.

The people of Warrnambool have also shown they are ready to embrace same-sex marriage, with the most recent poll by the local newspaper coming in at 72% support.

simon richardson

Byron Shire Mayor Simon Richardson has been leading a national push for councils to support marriage equality. Image: The Greens.

At its regular briefing yesterday, the council had an opportunity to decide whether to join these councils by acting on Mayor Richardson’s letter, together with a marriage equality proclamation that Byron Shire Council has asked each council to sign.

Only two councillors, both women – Cr Jacinta Ermacora and Cr Kylie Gaston – argued that Mayor Richardson’s request should be taken further.

The remaining five, including Mayor Michael Neoh, Cr Peter Sycopoulis and Cr Brian Kelson – who told Bluestone that they support equality – all agreed that it should instead be “parked” ie. do nothing.

This is not leadership. This is weak.

It is also supremely ironic that a council can name Shane Hernan as its Young Citizen of the Year in 2013, yet not consider it worthwhile to publicly support the very issues that Shane is fighting for.

Because it is one thing to support gays, lesbians and transgender people quietly behind the scenes, but another to stand publicly shoulder-to-shoulder when the going gets tough.

And believe me, the going has been tough.


While declaring he has no problem with marriage equality, W’bool Mayor Michael Neoh has not joined his fellow mayors in publicly supporting it. Image: WCC.

As it stands, there is not one political leader representing Warrnambool who will stand up for marriage equality: not Member for Wannon Dan Tehan, nor outgoing South West Coast MP Dr Denis Napthine, or state MLC James Purcell, or even, it has now come to pass, Mayor Michael Neoh.

In other words, the message to young gays and lesbians from our political leaders in south-west Victoria is that you are, and should remain, second class citizens.

What a terrible, isolating and discriminatory message.

And it is not just about young people. There are many older gays and lesbians living in Warrnambool who, despite their age and wisdom, are still too frightened to reveal their sexuality for fear of rejection.

I know how hard it can be. I grew up in Warrnambool and returned here determined not to retreat back into the closet. Bluestone has lost subscribers because of this, but, I would hope, we have also gained more.

Sexual identity is not something you can just turn on and off. Similarly, it is not enough to “like” gay people, provided they don’t act too gay or start asking for too much.

What is so heartening is that the majority of people in Warrnambool actually get this.

What is so disheartening is that the majority of our civic leaders don’t.

Please click here to subscribe and support Bluestone Magazine.

newsletter Eat And Drink StonesYou might also enjoy…

How CEO Bruce Anson appears to have a job for life

WCC Mackay trip: keeping it in the family

Tehan remains opposed to marriage equality

Where does the WCC stand on same-sex marriage?


  1. What a sorry bunch of Councillors we have. Thank goodness we have at least two who are living in the modern world and who are prepared to stand up for their beliefs.

  2. I just don’t get it! The majority of Warrnamboolians (and the majority of Australians) support same sex marriage and yet these so-called community representatives still can’t make a decision. What are they afraid of?

  3. Such a patheticly piss-weak stance by our WCC members. It’s an embarrassment to our great little city. WCC are suppose to stand with the community. Shame Neoh, Sycopoulis, Kelson, shame. Simply no balls.

  4. Jo Dover asked the right question: What ARE they afraid of? Ridiculous.

  5. I could be seen as one of those who support the gay society and over the years have had many friends who are gay, but perhaps because I am one of the ‘older’ generation I am still standing on the fence re gay marriage. I was disappointed to read that you have lost subscribers due to the fact that you, apparently, are gay, how small minded have those people been!

  6. Surprising Neoh not supportive… preselection for Napthines seat… shows where his prerogatives lie… Not So Liberal Party…

  7. How small minded are Warrnambool councillors? In this time in Australia’s history, people all over the country are embracing the concept that love is love, no matter who is in a relationship! I thought this neck of the woods, with its thriving art community, was far more open-minded and generous in their attitudes. This is obviously not reflected by the local politicians. Some of them must have been threatened by withdrawals of support or some such thing. Of course that’s pure speculation on my part, but usually money (or lack of) talks!

Share This